Peter Gerety usually plays a lot of cop roles in addition to judges/lawyers. In this episode of "Blue Bloods" he plays a Bishop and he looks good doing it. He should play a priest more often.
The major of Malachy McCourt roles revolve around some kind man of the clothe. Look at him, he sure has the right look for it.
Jack Lemmon in "Mass Appeal" which included an even hotter Charles Durning.
George Coe as Father William Donlan in an episode of "Bones."
Ian McNeice as a bishop in "Blak Plague." Even included a video for this one.
Funny and creepy at the same time but I mentally remove all the undesirable in my head to enjoy a nearly nude Ian. I mean really. How many times are you going to see a chubb his size with that much clothes off.
William Hill as Father Dan on an episode of "Rescue Me."
What better than Richard Riehle in street clothes. Richard Riehle naked. But close second, Richard Riehle in a priest uniform or a police uniform or so on and so forth.
These next group of actors actually studied to be priests before becoming actors which is kinda hot.
Dakin Matthews initially aspired to become a Roman Catholic priest, studying in San Francisco and then at Gregorian University in Rome in the 1960s.
Really? You can't tell me he doesn't look the part.
At one point, Bob Gunton had planned to become a Catholic priest before entering the Army. Again. He just looks the part.
Ralph Waite earned a master's degree from Yale University Divinity School and was an ordained Presbyterian minister before deciding on an acting career.